Choosing Dinner and Pleasing a Crowd

Last week I posted about dinnertime conversation and this week I’ll stay on the topic of dinner.  Our household includes three children and two parents and it’s tricky to please 5 different taste preferences for dinner every night.

About a year ago I hit the limit of comments that “I don’t like this” and “can I make myself a pb&j?”  I’m the primary cook in our house and I want to serve dinners that are nutritious and that my family likes but it was starting to feel impossible. I needed a change for my mental health’s sake.

At the Straw that Broke the Camel’s Back dinner, I started asking my kids what meals they DO enjoy.  Like the first-born, type-A, enneagram 1 that I am, I started a list of the meals I generally make and came up with 31, which included made-from-scratch options all the way to frozen pizza.  I tallied which family members like each one and ended with only 8 meals that all 5 of us agree are awesome.  This felt a little disheartening but also empowering that I know what will work consistently.

So the new plan became serving something from the 5/5 stars list on Monday and Tuesday and then the rest of the week serve other meals with lower ratings.  Anyone who doesn’t like dinner from Wednesday-on has the option of leftovers from the Monday and Tuesday preferred options.  

This plan has been a game changer.  I’m happy to say the list of 8 is growing as we add more meals and my kids start liking some that used to be on their do not like list.  

Oh and in case you’re wondering what’s on the 5/5 list:

  • Chili
  • Lasagna
  • Popcorn Chicken
  • Pork roast
  • Beef over noodles
  • Homemade chicken noodle soup
  • Grilled chicken breast
  • BLTs
  • Pizza
  • Spaghetti with meatballs
  • Beef tacos
  • Breakfast for dinner

School’s back in session which means I have a moment to write a post.  I love the feeling of back to school season.  The fresh start makes it a great time to set new intentions like connecting more as a family.  One of my favorite traditions at our house is to share our Rose-Thorn-Bud at dinner.  

This started years ago as sharing our Favorite thing (high) and Trouble (low) for the day.  When our son who was two he would say the exact same thing at every meal, “My favorite thing is I got to see all you guuuuys…and no trouble was.”  I can still hear that phrase in his toddler voice. 

Favorite Thing and Trouble has evolved over time to Rose-Thorn-Bud and I love that it stimulates conversation and gives us all a peek into each other’s day.  

It looks like this, with each person sharing:

  • Rose: something good that happened today
  • Thorn: something not so good that happened today
  • Bud: something you’re looking forward to 
  • Budthorn: (bonus 4th item my kids created to talk about something upcoming that induces dread i.e. vaccines, tests at school)

The only rule is that everyone has to have to have a rose.  A few times my kiddos have said it was a horrible day and there’s nothing good to share because it was a day of thorns only.  We remind them that those thorns are real.  It was a hard day.  We can experience those feelings and also find the tiniest piece of gratitude, even if it’s just that we have food to eat.  

Gratitude and connecting with others are helpful tools to improve our mental health.  If you’re looking to improve dinner time conversation, I hope you’ll give Rose-Thorn-Bud a try.